Two big names are facing off for American families. The Toyota Highlander is known for its durability and strong resale value. On the other hand, the GMC Acadia focuses on professional-grade design and powerful performance. This comparison aims to provide useful insights for families looking for a reliable SUV.
This head-to-head review offers a clear look at performance, technology, safety, price, and value. It’s designed to help buyers make an informed choice. Toyota and GMC represent different approaches: Toyota emphasizes long-term reliability and efficiency, while GMC offers bold styling and towing power. Both are great options for families, each with unique strengths.
Our analysis draws from past and present data. We look at how models like the 2017 Highlander Hybrid and the 2017 Acadia have evolved. Today’s comparison highlights modern features like driver aids, larger screens, and smarter design. It’s a practical guide for those seeking facts without unnecessary details.
Expect detailed specs, easy-to-understand explanations, and clear pros and cons. Whether you need a fuel-efficient ride or a powerful SUV for towing, this review helps. It’s a comparison built for busy families, starting right here.
Overview: Two Family-Friendly Midsize SUVs Built for American Roads
The Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia are top choices in the three-row crossover market. They’re designed for long trips and different weather conditions in the U.S. Both offer confident driving, flexible seating, and practical features for families.
Who They’re For: Family-oriented Toyota vs premium-leaning GMC
The Highlander is for families who value reliability and fuel efficiency. It’s easy to own and maintain. On the other hand, the Acadia is for those who want a premium feel, bold looks, and strong performance.
GMC’s Elevation, AT4, and Denali trims offer sporty, rugged, and luxury options. Toyota focuses on comfort and a wide range of features. Knowing these differences helps when choosing between the two.
Generations and Market Position
The Highlander started in 2001 and is now in its fifth generation, launched in 2020. The Acadia began in 2007 and is in its third generation, introduced in 2017. Both are in the midsize class, with three rows, lots of cargo space, and family-friendly design.
When comparing Highlander and Acadia, each is a strong contender. They offer modern safety features, all-wheel drive, and flexible seating for any road and weather.
Brand Reputation: Reliability vs professional-grade appeal
Toyota is known for its long-lasting vehicles, strong resale value, and low maintenance. GMC, on the other hand, focuses on professional-grade engineering and a premium look. This appeals to buyers looking for something more than the usual.
In a car buying guide, the Highlander is often praised for its durability and efficiency. The Acadia, with its design, trim options, and upscale features, offers a more luxurious driving experience.
Pricing and Value Proposition for United States Buyers
When comparing Highlander vs Acadia, pricing and standard features are key. This guide focuses on what you get for your money and how it affects long-term value in the U.S. It uses current reviews and past MSRPs for context.
Starting MSRPs and what they include
The Toyota Highlander starts at $41,315, while the GMC Acadia begins at $44,495. This price difference shows GMC’s premium focus. Both models come with three-row seating, active safety tech, and smartphone integration.
Trim levels vary, affecting content. Toyota often includes more safety features early on. GMC, on the other hand, focuses on luxury touches in Elevation, AT4, and Denali trims. This can justify higher prices for some buyers. Looking back, the 2017 Highlander Hybrid started at $36,270, while a 2017 Acadia was listed at $47,070, highlighting Toyota’s value.
Total ownership costs: maintenance, warranty, and resale outlook
Costs beyond the MSRP are important. Both brands offer similar warranties: 36 months/36,000 miles basic and 60 months/60,000 miles powertrain. Regular service intervals help manage costs, but Toyota is known for lower maintenance and fewer repairs.
Resale trends favor the Highlander, with strong demand and lower depreciation. The Acadia’s resale is solid but often trails the Highlander. Higher parts costs and maintenance in some areas are noted in reviews.
Which delivers better value for a car buying guide
Value depends on what you prioritize. Families looking for long-term savings might prefer the Highlander for its resale and maintenance costs. Those wanting premium features and unique trim content might find the Acadia more appealing, despite its higher starting price.
| Metric | Toyota Highlander | GMC Acadia | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Current Starting MSRP | $41,315 | $44,495 | Initial pricing sets total finance outlay and tax basis. |
| Historic MSRP Example (2017) | Highlander Hybrid: $36,270 | Acadia: $47,070 | Shows historical value patterns that inform expectations. |
| Warranty (Basic/Powertrain) | 36 mo/36,000 mi; 60 mo/60,000 mi | 36 mo/36,000 mi; 60 mo/60,000 mi | Similar coverage simplifies comparison in a car buying guide. |
| Maintenance Outlook | Lower average costs; predictable intervals | Potentially higher parts and scheduled costs | Impacts five-year budget and ownership value. |
| Resale/Demand | High demand; slower depreciation | Solid resale; may trail Toyota | Affects total cost of ownership at trade-in. |
| Trim Strategy | LE/XLE/XSE/Limited emphasize safety and utility | Elevation/AT4/Denali emphasize premium and capability | Feature bundles influence perceived value in vehicle reviews. |
Bottom line metrics help clarify Highlander vs Acadia for shoppers who rank value, pricing discipline, and feature content differently.
Highlander vs Acadia
In this SUV comparison, size and design are key. The Highlander is 194.5 inches long, 76.0 inches wide, and 68.1 inches tall. The Acadia is 193.4 inches long, 75.5 inches wide, and 66.5 inches tall. The Toyota is a bit longer and taller, while the GMC is lower for easier loading and a sleek look.
Cabin space is another area to consider. The Acadia has more legroom up front and in the second row. The Highlander has less legroom but is more comfortable. Both SUVs aim to be the best for families, but they focus on space differently.
Cargo space is where the GMC shines when all seats are up. The Acadia offers 23.0 cubic feet, while the Highlander has 16.0 cubic feet. When the second row is folded, both SUVs offer up to 97.5 cubic feet, making them great for hauling large items.
Powertrain performance is where the Acadia stands out. It has a 2.5-liter turbo engine that makes 328 horsepower and 326 pound-feet of torque. The Highlander’s 2.4-liter turbo engine makes 265 horsepower and 310 pound-feet of torque. The GMC offers stronger acceleration, while the Toyota is known for its smooth and quiet drive.
Efficiency is important in any comparison. The Highlander is estimated to get 22 mpg city and 29 mpg highway. The GMC Acadia gets 20 mpg city and 27 mpg highway. The Highlander Hybrid offers even better fuel efficiency for daily use.
Towing and tech are other areas to consider. The Acadia can tow up to 5,000 pounds, while the Highlander can tow up to 3,500 pounds. Inside, the GMC has a 15-inch center display, an 11-inch digital cluster, and available Super Cruise for hands-free driving.
Trim levels shape the personality of each SUV. Toyota offers LE, XLE, XSE, and Limited trims focused on comfort. GMC has Elevation, AT4, and Denali trims for urban style, off-road capability, and premium features.
| Key Theme | Toyota Highlander | GMC Acadia | What It Means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Exterior Size | 194.5 in L / 76.0 in W / 68.1 in H | 193.4 in L / 75.5 in W / 66.5 in H | Highlander is slightly longer and taller; Acadia is lower and a touch narrower. |
| Legroom (Front/2nd Row) | 42.0 in / 38.7 in | 44.28 in / 41.45 in | Acadia offers roomier seating for driver and second-row passengers. |
| Cargo Capacity | 16.0 ft³ (all seats up); up to 97.5 ft³ | 23.0 ft³ (all seats up); up to 97.5 ft³ | GMC leads with seats up; both maximize space with rows folded. |
| Power Output | 2.4L turbo, 265 hp / 310 lb-ft | 2.5L turbo, 328 hp / 326 lb-ft | Acadia delivers stronger acceleration; Highlander prioritizes smoothness. |
| Fuel Efficiency | 22/29 mpg (city/hwy); Hybrid available | 20/27 mpg (city/hwy) | Toyota leads in mpg and adds a hybrid option for greater efficiency. |
| Towing Capacity | 3,500 lbs | 5,000 lbs | Acadia suits heavier trailers; Highlander fits light-duty towing. |
| Technology | Large infotainment, extensive driver aids | 15-inch center screen, 11-inch cluster, HUD, available Super Cruise | GMC emphasizes high-end displays and hands-free capability. |
| Trim Personalities | LE, XLE, XSE, Limited | Elevation, AT4, Denali | Toyota vs GMC offers comfort-focused vs premium and off-road flavors. |
Engine Performance, Acceleration, and Towing Confidence
Drivers looking at midsize SUVs want real gains. This comparison focuses on engine response, speed, and towing capacity. It’s about performance for daily life and weekend adventures.
Powertrains and specs: turbo 2.4L (Highlander) vs turbo 2.5L (Acadia)
The Toyota Highlander has a 2.4-liter turbocharged engine. It makes 265 hp and 310 lb-ft of torque. The GMC Acadia has a 2.5-liter turbo, making 328 hp and 326 lb-ft.
The Acadia’s engine gives it a boost in speed. But the Highlander’s engine is smoother for family trips. The GMC’s power is better for high speeds, while the Highlander is more balanced.
On-road feel: throttle response, handling, and stability
Both SUVs have quick throttle response for city driving. The Acadia feels sportier, with faster downshifts and firmer handling. Its steering is precise and predictable.
The Highlander is calm on the highway. It handles bumps well and stays steady. Toyota focuses on comfort without losing responsiveness.
Towing comparison: 5,000 lbs (Acadia) vs 3,500 lbs (Highlander)
The Acadia can tow up to 5,000 pounds, giving it a big advantage. The Highlander can tow up to 3,500 pounds, good for small trailers. The Acadia’s power helps it climb hills better and pass easily.
GMC’s AT4 setup helps with towing on rough terrain. Toyota’s AWD system keeps the Highlander stable on wet roads.
| Specification | Toyota Highlander 2.4L Turbo | GMC Acadia 2.5L Turbo |
|---|---|---|
| Horsepower | 265 hp | 328 hp |
| Torque | 310 lb-ft | 326 lb-ft |
| Transmission | Automatic | Automatic |
| Drive Options | FWD or AWD | FWD or AWD (AT4 available) |
| Towing Capacity (max) | 3,500 lbs | 5,000 lbs |
| Character | Smooth, composed delivery | Straight-line punch, sportier tuning |
| Highlander vs Acadia Takeaway | Balanced daily performance | Stronger acceleration and towing confidence |
Fuel Economy and Efficiency Comparison
When comparing Highlander vs Acadia, fuel efficiency is a key factor. Both are great for families, but they have different engines. This affects how much fuel they use on daily drives and long trips.
| Model | Engine/Type | City MPG | Highway MPG | Combined MPG | Notable Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Toyota Highlander (gas) | 2.4L turbo I-4 | 22 | 29 | Approx. 25 | Consistent advantage of 2–3 mpg vs Acadia |
| GMC Acadia (gas) | 2.5L turbo I-4 | 20 | 27 | Approx. 23 | Strong torque aids efficiency under load |
| Toyota Highlander Hybrid | Hybrid 2.5L system | High 30s (typical) | Low–mid 30s (typical) | Best-in-class range | Hybrid advantage for commuters and long trips |
| Historical Reference: 2017 GMC Acadia | Gas | 18 | 25 | 20 | Past data shows no mpg lead |
| Historical Reference: 2017 Highlander Hybrid | Hybrid | — | — | 28 | Reinforces Toyota’s efficiency edge |
EPA-style ratings: city and highway differences
The Highlander gets better gas mileage than the Acadia. It has a 22 city and 29 highway mpg rating. The Acadia gets 20 city and 27 highway mpg.
On the highway, both SUVs are efficient. The Highlander is about 2 mpg better than the Acadia. This difference is important for SUVs that travel a lot.
Hybrid advantage: Highlander Hybrid for best-in-class efficiency
The Highlander Hybrid is very efficient without losing speed. It gets around 30 mpg combined, which is the best. The 2017 Hybrid had a 28 mpg combined rating, showing Toyota’s long lead.
The Hybrid uses less fuel in city driving. This is great for families who drive a lot in the city. It means fewer trips to the gas station.
Real-world savings over time for family-friendly SUVs
Using less fuel each year saves money. A 2–3 mpg difference can save dozens of gallons a year. This adds up over time, making the Highlander more cost-effective.
Towing and heavy loads might affect short-term fuel use. But over time, the Highlander’s better efficiency saves money. This is good for families who drive a lot.
Interior Comfort, Space, and Cargo Flexibility
Highlander vs Acadia examines daily comfort. Both can seat seven or eight, with comfy cushions and wide doors. You can choose from cloth to leather upholstery, and captain’s chairs improve access.
They both have quiet cabins and lots of storage. This makes long trips smoother and more organized.
The GMC Acadia has more interior space in some areas. It offers 44.28 inches of front legroom, more than the Highlander’s 42.0 inches. The second row has 41.45 inches in the Acadia, compared to 38.7 inches in the Highlander. This is great for tall teens and easier car-seat placement.
Both SUVs have a standard third row. The Acadia’s third row is slightly bigger, making it easier for kids to get in. Families looking for the best 3-row SUV will appreciate the quick-fold seats and wide cargo openings in both models.
The Acadia has more space behind the third row: 23.0 cubic feet compared to the Highlander’s 16.0 cubic feet. Both can expand to 97.5 cubic feet with the second row folded. This allows for easy storage of strollers, sports gear, or luggage.
The Acadia’s power-fold third row makes switching from passengers to cargo easy. It also has tie-downs and under-floor storage for keeping items secure. The Highlander has smart cubbies and a simple fold for the second row, making quick changes easy in both SUVs.
| Measure | Toyota Highlander | GMC Acadia | Takeaway for Families |
|---|---|---|---|
| Front Legroom | 42.0 in | 44.28 in | Acadia gives taller drivers extra knee stretch |
| Second-Row Legroom | 38.7 in | 41.45 in | Acadia eases car-seat installs and teen comfort |
| Third Row | Standard; slightly tighter | Standard; slightly roomier | Both fit kids; Acadia offers more adult-friendly space |
| Cargo Behind 3rd Row | 16.0 ft³ | 23.0 ft³ | Acadia holds more groceries and gear without folding seats |
| Max Cargo (seats folded) | Up to 97.5 ft³ | Up to 97.5 ft³ | Both handle bulk loads when reconfigured |
| Convenience Features | Quick-fold second row, abundant small-item storage | Power-fold third row, lower load height, tie-downs | Fast transitions for family trips and weekend projects |
For those comparing Highlander vs Acadia, these details highlight the daily differences. Both offer thoughtful interior space and flexible cargo capacity. They cater to the needs of busy American families in unique ways.
Technology, Infotainment, and Connectivity for Modern Families
Both SUVs offer tech for families. They have Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, with wireless pairing on most trims. Navigation is available, and touchscreens start at 8 inches, making it easy to use.
Recent reviews show GMC focuses on big screens and sound. Toyota focuses on clear menus and reliable connectivity. This shows the difference between Highlander and Acadia for those who want simple controls or a digital cockpit.
Screen sizes, smartphone integration, and navigation
The GMC Acadia has a 15-inch center display and an 11-inch digital gauge cluster. It also has an available Head-Up Display. Toyota Highlander has an intuitive interface with crisp graphics and standard Apple CarPlay/Android Auto, plus available built-in navigation.
Both start with 8-inch touchscreens and wireless connectivity on many trims. GMC and Toyota have evolved from early systems to today’s streamlined ones.
Audio and charging: wireless features and premium sound
GMC pairs the big screen with an available Bose premium audio system. It has multiple USB-C ports and wireless charging for family devices. Toyota has wireless charging on select trims, plenty of USB ports, and sound systems tuned for clear voice and podcast playback.
- Wireless smartphone charging available on both
- USB-C ports across all rows in many trims
- Premium audio option in the Acadia; straightforward tuning in the Highlander
User experience: interface responsiveness and ease of use
Acadia emphasizes speed and graphic polish, with Super Cruise for hands-free driving on compatible roads. Highlander focuses on clean menu logic and quick access to core infotainment features, which helps reduce distractions.
In daily use, the approach defines Highlander vs Acadia: Toyota aims for simple, repeatable tasks; GMC aims for a high-tech feel. For shoppers reading vehicle reviews, the choice often comes down to whether expansive screens or intuitive controls matter more to their routine.
| Feature | Toyota Highlander | GMC Acadia |
|---|---|---|
| Center Display | Standard 8-inch; clear, user-friendly UI | Up to 15-inch; high-resolution, feature-dense |
| Driver Display | Configurable cluster on select trims | 11-inch digital cluster available |
| Smartphone Integration | Apple CarPlay/Android Auto; wireless on many trims | Apple CarPlay/Android Auto; wireless on many trims |
| Navigation | Available built-in mapping | Available built-in mapping |
| Audio | Tuned for clarity; family-friendly balance | Bose premium system available |
| Charging | Wireless charging available; multiple USB ports | Wireless charging available; multiple USB-C ports |
| Advanced Aids | Straightforward interface priorities | Available Head-Up Display and Super Cruise |
Shoppers comparing infotainment and connectivity will find parity in essentials. GMC pushes scale and features, while Toyota refines the day-to-day experience. This helps anchor Highlander vs Acadia for tech-focused families.
Safety Features, Ratings, and Driver Assistance
Families look at Highlander vs Acadia to understand safety and driver help. This guide offers clear, tested info for buying a car.
Standard safety equipment on both SUVs
Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia come with many safety features. They have airbags, ABS, electronic stability control, and a tire pressure monitor. A rearview camera helps with parking and picking up kids from school.
Both SUVs also have hill-start assist and traction control. They make it easy to install child seats and remind you to buckle up in every row.
Advanced driver assistance: Toyota Safety Sense vs GMC safety suite
Toyota Safety Sense 2.5+ includes adaptive cruise control and lane departure alert. It also has automatic emergency braking and can detect pedestrians. Road sign assist and lane tracing assist help on long drives.
GMC Pro Safety and GMC Pro Safety Plus offer similar tech. They have adaptive cruise control and automatic emergency braking. Lane departure warning and lane keep assist are common. Higher trims add Super Cruise for driving on compatible roads without your hands.
Family peace of mind: braking, lane support, and cameras
Both SUVs have front pedestrian automatic emergency braking and rear cross traffic alert. Parking sensors and surround-view cameras are available for better visibility.
Lane support systems keep you in your lane, even in windy conditions. Strong emergency braking and clear camera views give parents and teen drivers confidence. This is important when comparing Highlander vs Acadia.
Ride Quality, Trims, and Long-Term Ownership
The way a car feels and what it offers matters a lot to families over time. How smooth it rides, how quiet the cabin is, and the features it has all play a part. These things affect daily life, weekend trips, and how well the car holds its value. People also think about how reliable it is, how much maintenance it needs, and what warranty it comes with.
Driving character: comfort-first Highlander vs sportier Acadia
The Highlander is made for a smooth ride. It handles bumps well and keeps the noise down at high speeds. Its steering is easy to manage, perfect for daily driving.
The Acadia, on the other hand, is sportier. It responds quickly to the driver and stays stable in turns. It also comes with AWD for better traction on wet roads. The AT4 model adds features for off-roading, like hill descent control and special suspension.
Trim strategies: LE/XLE/XSE/Limited vs Elevation/AT4/Denali
Toyota offers a range of trims, from the basic LE to the luxurious Limited. Each step up adds more features, like heated seats and bigger wheels, without confusion.
GMC’s Elevation is sporty and clean. The AT4 is rugged, with all-terrain tires and off-road-ready features. The Denali is luxurious, with LED lights and premium interior options for those who want the best.
Maintenance expectations and reliability considerations
When it comes to maintenance, Toyota is known for being predictable. Its parts are easy to find, which keeps costs down. GMC might need more frequent visits to the shop and could have pricier parts in some areas.
Both brands offer similar warranties, covering basic and powertrain for about 8 years or 100,000 miles. But, Toyota’s reputation for durability helps its resale value. GMC, on the other hand, offers more capability and tech, which appeals to those who value performance and features.
- Key takeaways: quiet ride vs sporty tuning, clear trims progression, predictable service vs feature-rich capability
- Consider commute miles, towing needs, and regional service network before choosing
Conclusion
In this Highlander vs Acadia SUV comparison, the results are clear. GMC offers more power and towing capacity, with 328 hp and 326 lb-ft. It also has a 5,000-lb towing rating. The Acadia wins in third-row space and tech, with a 15-inch display and Super Cruise.
The Acadia has more cargo space when all seats are up, at 23.0 ft³. But both SUVs can carry a lot when needed. This makes them great for trips.
Toyota starts at $41,315, cheaper than GMC’s $44,495. It also gets better gas mileage, at 22/29 mpg. The Highlander Hybrid is even more fuel-efficient, with a history of 28 mpg combined.
Toyota focuses on comfort and reliability, important for families. Both SUVs have strong safety features. But Toyota often includes more standard safety features.
If you want power, tech, and towing, the Acadia is the better choice. For those who value efficiency, cost, and reliability, the Highlander is the way to go. Test driving both is key to finding the right SUV for you.
For American buyers, this comparison reveals two winners. The GMC Acadia is great for those who need power and tech. The Toyota Highlander is ideal for those looking to save on fuel, value, and peace of mind.
FAQ
Which is better for families, the Toyota Highlander or GMC Acadia?
Both are great for families. The Highlander is good for those who want to save money. It’s reliable, efficient, and has a lower starting price.
The Acadia is for those who want luxury and power. It has more legroom, a bigger third row, and advanced tech like a 15-inch screen. Your choice depends on what you value most.
How do the starting prices compare for U.S. buyers?
The Highlander starts at ,315, while the Acadia starts at ,495. The Acadia costs more because it’s premium and has more tech.
Trim and options can make the Acadia even pricier. But the Highlander has more affordable trims.
Which SUV has better fuel economy?
The Highlander is more fuel-efficient. It gets 22 mpg city and 29 mpg highway. The Highlander Hybrid is even better, making it the top choice for fuel.
How do the engines and performance differ?
The Acadia’s 2.5L turbo engine has 328 hp and 326 lb-ft for quick acceleration. The Highlander’s 2.4L turbo has 265 hp and 310 lb-ft for smooth power.
Those who want strong performance might choose the Acadia. But the Highlander is better for those who value fuel efficiency.
What are the towing capacities?
The Acadia can tow up to 5,000 pounds, great for boats and small trailers. The Highlander can tow up to 3,500 pounds, good for lighter loads.
Which model has more passenger space and cargo room?
The Acadia has more legroom and a bigger third row. It also has 23.0 cubic feet of space behind the third row. The Highlander has less legroom but can also carry a lot of cargo.
How do the interiors and trims compare?
The Highlander focuses on comfort and quiet. The Acadia offers different personalities like Elevation, AT4, and Denali. Both have cloth to premium leather options and storage solutions.
Which SUV offers better technology and screens?
The Acadia has a huge 15-inch center display and an 11-inch digital cluster. It also has a Head-Up Display and premium Bose audio. Both have Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, and the Highlander is easy to use.
How do the safety features compare?
Both have a strong safety suite with airbags, stability control, and rearview cameras. The Highlander has adaptive cruise control and lane departure warning as standard. The Acadia has similar features and advanced options like Super Cruise.
Which has the better ride and handling?
The Highlander is quiet and balanced, perfect for daily driving. The Acadia is sportier with quick acceleration and confident cornering. The AT4 trim is great for off-road adventures.
What about ownership costs and long-term value?
Toyota is known for reliability and lower maintenance costs, making the Highlander a good long-term choice. GMC’s Acadia may have higher costs but offers premium features and power. Warranty coverage is similar.
How do historical models inform today’s choices?
Older models show Toyota’s focus on efficiency and GMC’s emphasis on power. Today, the Highlander is efficient and affordable, while the Acadia offers performance and tech.
Which is the best 3-row SUV for city driving and weekend trips?
The Highlander is great for city driving and long trips because of its fuel economy and comfort. The Acadia is better for towing and weekend trips with its tech and amenities. Test-driving both will help you decide.
Does the Acadia’s higher price deliver extra value?
Yes, for those who want more power, towing, and tech like the 15-inch display and Super Cruise. But the Highlander is better for long-term value.
Is there a clear winner in this SUV comparison?
It depends on what you value most. Choose the Highlander for fuel economy and lower costs. Choose the Acadia for power, space, and premium features. Both are excellent choices.